Wagnerian singers don’t grow on trees…
One question I'm invariably asked when people learn that I sing Wagner is 'how do you become a Wagnerian?'. The music is on a scale like no other, and as someone remarked to me recently, Wotans and Brünnhildes don't grow on trees.
Read the full post
Comment from Louise Armstrong
Louise Armstrong said ago
I loved this concert performance - so much easier to hear the singers when they can stand at the front and simply sing. Woeful/Sigmund stood out for me, and Wotan was moving in the last act. Beautiful playing from the orchestra all through. The surtitles were well written, making sense of the bonkers plot, but the presentation was a disgrace! The lettering was white, and shown over photographs or pale grey clouds! Can't wait for the next installment.
Comment from ToffeeTim
ToffeeTim said ago
Wonderful. Surpassed my expectations musically and dramatically with just enough "acting". Pity about the background for the subtitles and Fricka's which were right at the top of the screen so the top line was not visible and there were 5 rows behing me! This could have been fixed.
Comment from Alex Frost
Alex Frost said ago
Returned disappointed after a long journey from the Sage. My comments mirror many I spoke with. While Sieglinde, the orchestra and Fricka were excellent, and the staging well thought out, Brunnhilde was unimpressive and critically there was no chemistry between her and an increasingly tedious Wotan (although he did soften in the right places, it was by then irrelevant); so Act II was marred and III spoiled knowing the final scene would be (and was) a let down before it even arrived. Most of all I'm upset with the reviewers and media for the hype; every seat was filled and I made a 10 hour return journey. Let's be realsitic and not throw 5* recommendations around like confetti when they simply aren't justified.
Comment from Neville
Neville said ago
I attended one of the Leeds Town Hall performances of Die Walkure. It was simply superb. I was fortunate enough to attend the ENO Ring in Leeds, back in the seventies. This was easily its equal, and in terms of orchestral playing, far, far superior. I recorded the Radio 3 Die Walkure evening on 20/6/12, but sadly I accidentally deleted it. If anyone could lend me a copy that I can duplicate and return, I would be eternally grateful. Nevleeds@hotmail.com
Comment from Elizaveta
Elizaveta said ago
I was at the performance in Birmingham yesterday. Die Walküre is my favourite opera but this was my first experience listening to it live. And what an experience it was! Béla Perencz was especially striking. It is really great to hear a Wotan who sounds godlike but clearly has human feelings. Annalena Persson and Alwyn Mellor convinced me that good Wagnerian sopranos do exist these days, those who can not only sing the notes but also portray convicingly those heroines of the Ring, valiant and strong-willed but sometimes touching and vulnerable. Erik Nelson Werner sometimes reminded me of Jon Vickers' recordings. He is a romantic Siegmund, especially great in milder moments like Winterstürme. However, his call for the sword in Act I stroke me, together with Wagner's orchestra, like a thunderbolt. I listened to this moment many times in recording, but until yesterday I never realised how powerful it is. Thank you very much for this great production, and I am looking forward to listening to Siegfried next year!
[And I agree with another commentator that the backgroud for the surtitles should have been darker. It was not easy to read them as they were.]
Comment from David Morgan
David Morgan said ago
Thank you Opera North for a wonderful evening of Wagner in Birmingham last night. I am waiting with baited breath for the next 2 installments. You have demonstrated to other opera companies how to produce a concert performance that is better than a full-scale production. More please!
May I make two constructive criticisms. In Rhinegold, i felt the screened images complimented the performance. Last night, some of the images were obstrusive and i had to close my eyes at times. To be subtle is better! Secondly, I had problems reading the text - white text on a light background does not work. The elderly lady sat next to me could not read any of the text. Hope this is helpful.
Comment from Deborah
Deborah said ago
Have just returned from the performance at Symphony Hall, Birmingham. Absolutely Wow-wow-wow!!! Wonderful to hear Wagner sung rather than shouted. For my 77 year companion, this was her first experience of the Ring - and she was completely won over, not dozing even once. Rapturous applause from a very full house, deservedly so. Exciting and moving in equal measure - so there's no way I'll sleep tonight! Thank you everyone for a terrific night - just disappointed that I can't see it at least one more time!
Comment from Mary Oswell
Mary Oswell said ago
Heard this brilliant production at The Sage Gateshead on Saturday and I'm still listening to the Leeds Radio 3 version online! Opera North has perfected the art (and it is an art) of the Concert Performance: most of the singing is towards the auditorium, just the occasional touch, look, gesture, kiss provide poignant interactions. The unhurried movement with a relatively static stage, allowed us to pay great attention to the superlatively interpreted music, unhindered by intrusive or annoying business between the singers (remember Chereau?). Who were, by the way, marvellous: invidious to pick out individuals, but Alwyn Mellor's Sieglinde was incandescent; Bela Perencz had me in tears when he bade farewell to Brunnhilde (such tenderness after such wrath); Katarina Karneus was a wonderfully bitchy bullying wife; and didn't Annalena Persson do well? Especially when you remember she was too ill to sing 3 days earlier.
A scintillating, illuminating evening: it was great to be able to see, and really appreciate, the magnificent playing of the ON orchestra. (Superlative woodwind, btw.) The only tiny thing... I kept wondering if the (miracle working) Richard Farnes would fall off his rail-less podium!
Comment from Tim Hills
Tim Hills said ago
A terrific production and also a superb way of introducing Wagner to newcomers. No incomprehensible big, bad Gesamtkunstwerk here -- just impact and clarity. Quite a few other operas might benefit from the same approach: dynamic video backpieces, real-time plot summaries and explanations, substantial surtitles dynamically keyed to the position of the current singer, to name a few.
Comment from Nicholas Dobson
Nicholas Dobson said ago
Saw last night - for the second time. Excellent production. Many thanks to everyone concerned for the extremely hard and co-ordinated work which has paid off handsomely. Particular credit to Kelly Cae Hogan for heroically - as befits a Valkyrie! - stepping in at the last moment for Annalena Persson who had rehearsed the role. If you're toying with the idea of going to see the production at one of the venues, toy no more. Just go!
Comment from Barbara Kelly
Barbara Kelly said ago
What a stupendous performance we had yesterday of Die Walkure. It was spine tingling both in terms of singing voices and the orchestra - the hours flew by unnoticed. What wonderful Valkyries we heard and saw - women not to be messed with, go and see them and a heart rendding Brunnhilde and Sieglinde with a voice like an angel.
Comment from Adam Baldwin
Adam Baldwin said ago
It is for nights like Saturday's performance of Walkure that I go to the opera. I was enthralled and moved by the human drama unfolding, and entirely lost in admiration for the conducter, orchestra and cast. A score and story I know reasonably well had me on the edge of my seat, my hands gripping its arms in tension and excitement. My thanks as an audience member to all involved in this intelligent and gripping production. Roll on Siegfried......
Comment from Graham Douglas
Graham Douglas said ago
A wonderful performance and the audience were rightly indebted to Miss Hogan who stepped up to the mark admirably under very difficult circumstances.
We had Wagnerian singing and Orchestral playing that stands comparison with any company in the world and should be very pleased with Opera North.
Comment from Paul Caldwell
Paul Caldwell said ago
A terrific rendition of Valkyrie. The semi-staged and intimate venue enhanced and added poignancy to the theme of Wotans duty to uphold high cold morality contrasting with the low warmth of humanity. This is often lost in its normal staging.
Its a shame that we have to wait a year for the next cycle.